Saturday, August 24, 2013

Homework - Still

One of the things I have been thinking about for the upcoming school year is - Homework. Over the last two years, I have attempted to limit the amount of homework assigned, made it as relevant as possible, and designed it to practice what we have been working on in class. Even with those modifications, that has not really improved the quality of what is submitted. Since homework was designed as practice, my policy was to count homework for effort, not accuracy. It would end up counting about 20% of a term grade and was a way to encourage students to show consistent effort and improvement through practice. However, the game for many of my students often was to submit something that was complete enough - for the grade - with not really much learning or practicing going on. It mainly served as a way to inflate their grades.

Eliminating homework altogether is an option that I considered. Pernille Ripp posted an excellent post recently about getting rid of homework in 11 steps. It had me almost convinced to go that route. The primary problem with this approach is my belief, for now anyway, that while we definitely practice in class what we are studying, enough practice on math concepts is not possible only in the classroom - at least for a majority of my students.

So that left me stuck with what to do for this year. For now, I have decided to continue to assign homework on many nights. It will also continue to be designed for practice and/or enrichment but it will not count towards a grade. My thought is that with the removal of the grading game, those that do it, hopefully most of them he said naively, will be truly doing it for practice and to improve their skills. When I check the work they submit, the feed back I give should also be more meaningful and open up further avenues of discussion and learning between us; student and teacher.

Sunday, June 23, 2013

Where to go after Year 1/2

As the school year nears an end, it seems like a good idea to assess the first half year of using Ipads in my classroom. Our school went 1:1 this year. The students were given access to Ipads in February. They did not go home with the children and current plans are for them to stay at school for next year as well.

What worked

Google Drive and Notability for homework and class work - While not nearly a 100% success and hampered by the Ipads staying in school, this workflow significantly reduced the amount of paper used and more importantly, for the students that submitted their assignments using Notability, increased the ability for interaction between us and served as a great way to have their work easily accessible to them.

Google Forms in the classroom -  I was very pleased with the ability to improve formative assessments and enhance classroom engagement and participation through the use of Google Forms. A description of one of their uses in the classroom can be found here. My original plans were to use Socrative for this type of assessment but never got around to really doing it. I still think Socrative can play a significant role for formative assessments in my classroom.

Enhancing classroom discussion - Access to the Internet at the fingertips of each student can be a blessing. There were several instances in class where students checked on something we were discussing. The information they found was able to improve our classroom discussion. Topics checked included the concept of infinity, the concepts of multiple dimensions, and the feasibility of continuing to produce pennies. In addition, some of my students also took on the role of fact checker. One example - When discussing positive and negative relationships between two variables - the speed of pitcher's fastball and the number of strikeouts that occur - I mentioned that Nolan Ryan had the record for most strikeouts. Blank stares from the audience as my age is showing and nobody knew who he was - until someone checked that indeed I was correct and how incredible his strikeout stats were.

What did not work

Note taking - I had planned to have students use Evernote and Skitch for their note taking and spent a couple of days at the beginning of the Ipad roll-out explaining how to use these new tools. While i believe about 20-25% of my students did make good use of the capabilities of these apps, it never felt to me that enough students really "got it" and many of them wanted to use other methods and apps. That is fine, except when each app has different limitations, it becomes difficult to manage what they are doing and how they can gain access across platforms.

Too much of a distraction  - I was most disappointed with the amount of distraction that the Ipad served for too many students. Despite much preparation and anticipation of this, it still ended up being more of a problem than I had anticipated and was prepared for. I had no interest in being an Ipad policeman but at the very least, I was an Ipad truant officer too many times. On some days, I admit to thinking that the whole 1:1 thing was not such a good idea.

Ipads staying in school - Keeping the Ipads in school limits the ability of many students to use the interactive capabilities of some of the apps used in class at home. In particular the ability to edit PDF documents and then submit them as assignments is not easy. As of yet, I have not figured out a suitable workaround for those that do not also have access to an Ipad at home.

Where to go/What to work on

(This is only a beginning list)

Use and curate digital resources - I need to use the resources of Net Texts and other digital platforms to supplement our textbook. Much of the content I present in class is via Smart Notebook files created by me that are based on topics from the text. More effort is needed to branch out and access and curate the readily available digital resources to enhance my presentation.

Improve classroom procedures - Clearly much more thought needs to be given on how to reduce the distractions of the Ipads while not limiting them or policing them too stringently. Not sure exactly what I will come up with at this time but I know the practices I used this last half of the year need to be significantly tweaked. It will be an interesting balancing act.

Note taking and in-class work - Again I am not sure at this point exactly what will be changed but I need to reconfigure the way notes are taken, referred to, and distributed in class. Too much inefficiency and wasted time was involved in the process used the last half of the year.

Continue to enhance classroom formative assessment - More uses of Google Forms and Socrative-like tools need to be thought of and woven into my classroom procedures. It was one of the highlights of the Ipad deployment but I know it can be improved upon.

Creating - Much of my summer planning will revolve around ways to attempt to continue to shift my classroom to one where the students create more and consume less. It will be a challenge but to use the abilities of what the Ipad brings to the classroom, a necessary one to think about and begin to undertake.



Saturday, June 22, 2013

Shout out

While school has not quite ended yet, (we end on the 25th due to several snow days), I wanted to give a recognition to two excellent resources for teaching mathematics, Estimation 180 created by Andrew Stadel and Visual Patterns created by Fawn Nguyen and a shout out to Andrew and Fawn.

The lack of a well developed number sense that many of my students possessed this year was bothersome and with the pressure of standardized testing gone, during the last month and a half of school I experimented with these resources.

During this time period, I started most lessons with an estimation task from Estimation 180 as a warm-up. I made a screen capture of the days estimate in a Smart Notebook file as a way to present it. To record their estimates, the students completed a Google Form that was modified from the Make an Estimate form that Andrew has on the side of each estimation. After each class, I parsed each classes results into a class specific spreadsheet. The following day, we would look at the answer to the most recent estimate, discuss the estimates that the class had made, and then do the next estimation. (In particular, the children seemed to enjoy watching the video answers). We started with some of the counting estimations, then moved to ones that involved length, ones that involved volume, and ended with ones that involved coins and their values.

The process worked pretty well and while anecdotal, the children definitely seemed to develop a much better way of explaining their reasoning and using previous clues and information to help with their new estimations. In  particular, by the time we ended with the coin tasks, more than half of each class was nailing their estimations. They of course asked all the usual questions about Mr. Stadel - what is his job?, (he is a math teacher) - does he have a life?, (yes, obviously), does he eat the candy/drink the soda presented in his estimations?, (I do not know), can he come to visit?, (he has offered to come if we pay his expenses).

While I did not use the Visual Patterns web site on a daily basis, I did use it on more than a dozen occasions during the last month and a half. To get the children to record their thoughts and slow their thinking process down a bit so they would not miss some of the subtle changes in the different patterns, I used the form that Fawn provided on the site. I do think that next school year I will attempt to develop a Google form for this because when their results are displayed, it will help all students see the thinking process of their classmates. It will also help them to slow down their thinking process even more as the desire to rush to an answer was still quite prevalent, (even with the use of the form).

We were not able to get to some of the more complicated patterns but in particular some of the beginning patterns with the circles, (pattern 5 and pattern 15), the penguins, (pattern 8), and the surface area with the cubes, (pattern 2) brought out some spirited discussion regarding their predictions. The work in figuring out the patterns offered from this site will significantly help improve my students ability to recognize mathematical patterns.

I will be using both of these resources on a routine basis during the next school year. They will provide a significant enhancement to my teaching as evidenced by my positive experiences for the last month and a half. I would like to thank both Andrew and Fawn for their tremendous effort and willingness to share. Actually I am in awe of their ability to provide these resources while teaching! Their contributions to teaching middle school mathematics cannot be overstated.

Sunday, March 3, 2013

Google Forms for quick assessment

It has been much too long since I have posted anything related to teaching.

We have officially been 1:1, (each student has access to an IPad2), in our middle school for about three weeks. One of the things I tried last week that worked quite well was using Google Forms as a warm-up/quick assessment tool.

It is fairly easy to create a Google Form. I used two main styles of forms, one that required numerical answers, and another that allowed more of a paragraph text-based answer. I conditionally formatted the forms that required a numerical answer to be color coded to easily see how the class did. The paragraph-text based answer forms were left as is.

The part that I felt worked nicely was displaying the results to the class in near real-time. I set up a link to the days warm-up form from our class website. Each student accessed and completed the form using their IPads and after about five minutes or so, I displayed the results to the class. We were able to discuss the results in a very timely fashion. (The class enjoyed seeing their responses on the board and watching the stragglers responses pop up while we were discussing the results). It helped me quickly identify what concepts from the previous lesson needed to be reinforced and also served as a focal point for the days lesson.This process could also be used towards the end of a lesson as a type of exit ticket approach.

I had used Google Forms for homework earlier in the year but found that the process did not lend itself to mathematics really well as it encouraged just the writing of an answer with little in the way of working out the problem. So I had gotten away from using the Forms for mathematics but for a quick formative assessment, I feel this method has considerable worth.

I have toyed with the idea of employing Flubaroo scripts with Google Forms for quizzes and tests. It is a pretty nifty scripting tool but has limitations for mathematics with once again, the showing of work part, so for now, I am holding off on using it. I would say that if your assessments are primarily multiple choice and/or short answer based, you might want to explore this script as a way to help in the assessment and grading of your student's work.

Saturday, January 26, 2013

Further preparations

The seventh grade students at MSMS will be getting their IPads on Thursday, the 31st. It is quite an exciting time. In preparation for changes in workflow that I would like to implement, this past week rather than hand out assignments, I started putting their assignments in a shared class folder in PDF format. This hopefully will get them used to the process of accessing their assignments online rather than being handed a paper copy.

Also, I created an individual shared folder for each student and sent them an e-mail link for that folder on Monday. It is my plan that this folder will be the location where they will put their completed work. A couple of students have already mastered the process but it seems that for the vast majority of my students, they are content to continue to access the assignments from our class web site.

Next week, when all students have the IPad and we are using them during class, I can have all of them access a PDF file from the shared class folder, open it in Notability and work on it, save the file and download it to their individual shared work folder on Google Drive. I can see from their reticence to use the shared class folder, that there will be some bumps in the road to these workflow changes.

I look forward to learning with my students how best to weave the IPad into our daily class work to improve our workflow and our mathematics learning.

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

New Year's Day 2013

More than 140 characters so a short post will have to do......

I have never been one for resolutions and the like at this time of year which means there will not be any lists. But I would like to state how happy I am with my decision to join Twitter this summer. I was not sure exactly what to expect and even as my experience with the medium evolves, thanks are in order. There are so many excellent educators and fine people out there willing to share some of their craft, ideas, and just as importantly, their compassion and sense of humor. The exposure to that sharing has improved my teaching and coping skills. To those I follow, thanks very much.

If you are reading this, my hope for you is to have as Healthy and as Happy a New Year as is possible!